logo
Home
The Campaign
News&Events
The Campaign
Resourses
Join
Regional contacts
Our story
Links
Merchandise
 
 


News

Recent Appointments

Future Events

Reports

Talks & Addresses

line

NEWS

OUTCOME OF GENERAL SYNOD, JULY 2010

REASONS TO BE OPTIMISTIC

1. Synod’s decision is good news for the Church

• Synod’s endorsement of the draft legislation is a decisive step forward. It allows women to be bishops without dismantling the office of bishop and offers space to those opposed. It is a good and generous compromise.
• It relies on trust not legal separation.
• It is good news for the Church.

2. A Generous Compromise

The draft legislation is a generous compromise because
• Those in favour of women bishops dropped their insistence on the simplest possible legislation in order to include as many people as possible.
• Provision is made for parishes opposed to women’s ordained ministry to have a male priest and/or a male bishop via Letters of Request.
• The Code of Practice and Diocesan Schemes will aim to ensure that those male priests and bishops are in fact acceptable to the requesting parishes.

3. The draft legislation had overwhelming support – other ways of accommodating those opposed did not.

The draft legislation proposed by the Revision Committee had overwhelming support from Synod (373/14).
Other ways of accommodating those opposed were all rejected by Synod: separate dioceses (258/134), transfer (270/175), and co-ordinate jurisdiction (by Houses)
• The Archbishops’ Amendment for co-ordinate jurisdiction did not command enough support to succeed by Houses. Each House was significantly divided. (Bishops 25/15, Clergy 85/90, Laity 106/86)
• This draft legislation is the way forward that best unites the church.

THE NEXT STAGE

Discussion in the dioceses

• The Draft Legislation now goes to the dioceses for discussion and approval.
• When it returns to General Synod it will need a 2/3 majority in each house to pass.
• This is a very high threshold but is achievable with a Synod that properly reflects opinion across the church as a whole.

New Synod

• The final vote will be taken by a new Synod elected this autumn.
• Those opposed are aiming to stop the legislation by packing Synod with their supporters.
• It is vitally important that people who support the full inclusion of women stand for Synod and that everyone uses their vote wisely.

PLEASE CONSIDER STANDING FOR GENERAL SYNOD

You will not split the vote.

We can support you.

Papers are out already.

The deadline for nominations is 3rd September.

This text above is available as a Word document to download here (to facilitate easier printing).



Both sides compromise as draft legislation goes forward for discussion in the dioceses


Today the General Synod overwhelmingly endorsed the draft legislation prepared by the Revision Committee with only a couple of minor amendments. After rejecting the ways of accommodating those opposed, that were debated on Saturday, Synod accepted the proposals suggested by the Revision Committee in clause 2 of the draft legislation.

After a moving debate, the motion was passed with an overwhelming majority; 373 in favour; 14 against with 17 abstentions.
Several powerful speeches made it clear the sacrifice that had been made by the majority who welcomed women's ordained ministry in voting for this compromise. "This is good news for the whole Church and we are delighted" says the Revd Rachel Weir, Chair of WATCH. "Synod's decision gives the Church a powerful mandate to move forward enthusiastically; welcoming the ministry of women at all levels within the Church whilst making space for those who are opposed to stay within our body".

Contacts: Revd Rachel Weir: Chair of WATCH 07815 729 565
Hilary Cotton: Vice Chair and Campaign Coordinator 07793 817 958
Sally Barnes: Media Officer 0208 731 9860 / 07759 343 335



Vote on Archbishops' amendment is standard practice


WATCH is disappointed that some opponents of women bishops are seeking to discredit the standard practices of General Synod after the vote on the Archbishops’ amendment yesterday. The procedure of votes being taken “by houses” is standard practice for many issues. It must be requested from the floor and supported by 25 members of synod. Once this decision is taken, the votes of each House of Synod (Bishops, Clergy and Lay) are added separately. A majority is required in all three houses for the motion to be carried. This ensures that all three groups are prepared to support a proposal and the Church can move forward together.

Ironically the same procedure was used in 1978 when Synod first fully considered ordaining women as deacons, priests and bishops. Although it obtained a majority overall, the motion failed to achieve a majority in the House of Clergy and therefore fell.

“It is important that we all continue to honour the processes of Synod and move forward in the light of the decisions they have made,” said the Revd Rachel Weir, Chair of WATCH. “ We hope and trust that the graciousness and attentive listening that characterised Saturday’s debate continues on Monday when Synod completes its consideration of the draft legislation.

Supporting the draft legislation represents a significant compromise for WATCH and others who support women’s ordained ministry: a compromise made in a spirit of generosity to make space for those opposed.”

WATCH looks forward to these proposals going forward to the wider church for further consultation.



Full Steam Ahead for Women Bishops – Church can move forward at last


WATCH is delighted that the Church has today affirmed its wish to appoint women as bishops on the same basis as men.

The General Synod, meeting in York, re-iterated its decision of July 2008 that when women are appointed bishops they will be in charge of their entire Diocese. Amendments suggesting that there should be separate dioceses for those opposed, or permanent flying bishops, or that parishes should automatically be transferred to another bishop, were all rejected by the Synod.

Hilary Cotton, Vice-Chair of WATCH, said, ‘We are absolutely delighted that Synod has stuck with its decision of two years ago and wants women to be bishops with full authority. This is good news for all women, not just women in the Church.’

Rachel Weir Chair of WATCH said, ”This has been an agonisingly slow journey and the Church has rightly wanted to do all it could for those who find this difficult, but we are delighted that Synod has made the right decision in the end”. Now at last the Church can move forward and accept the wonderful gifts of leadership that our women bring”

On Monday the Synod will decide what minor amendments to make. It will also be given the opportunity to vote for the simplest possible legislation, in other words that ‘the Church will appoint male and female bishops’. Arrangements for those opposed would then be entrusted to individual bishops under a Code of Practice that will be drawn up in the near future.

This is not the end of the journey. The wider Church will now be invited to debate the proposals and if approved General Synod will have a final vote on them in about eighteen months time.



WATCH opposes Archbishops' amendment regarding women bishops

The text of the Archbishops’ amendment on women bishops appears innocuously brief and simple. However, their proposed small alterations to the draft legislation hide some changes for the Church that WATCH sees as highly contentious.

In removing the reference to ‘delegation’ we are returned to the idea of ‘transfer’ of jurisdiction: a female bishop will have some of her job automatically removed as soon as she is appointed. This was rejected (as TEA) by the House of Bishops in 2006, and found unworkable in practice after detailed examination by the Revision Committee.

When it comes to having ‘coordinate jurisdiction’, the Archbishops appear to be seeking to create, in effect, two Diocesan bishops in each Diocese: one to minister to those who accept ordained women, and one to minister to those who don’t. This is a step further even than flying bishops. Such an innovation must not be accepted without serious examination of the consequences.

Senior clergywomen have written in the last week to the Archbishops asking them to withdraw their amendment. They say that the proposed amendment ‘brings dismay and despair amongst women priests, and many have voiced their reaction by saying how deeply undermining it is of their ministry as ordained women.’

WATCH remains opposed to the Archbishops’ amendment.



REV RACHEL WEIR SUCCEEDS CHRISTINA REES AS CHAIR OF WATCH

Revd Rachel Weir was elected the new Chair of WATCH at a General Meeting of members on 20th March. Two new Vice-Chairs were also elected at the meeting: Hilary Cotton and Revd Mark Bennett. Read the profiles of the new team below.

The Venerable Christine Allsopp paid tribute to the outgoing Chair Christina Rees and thanked her on behalf of all members for her long years of service to the organisation. Thanks were also given to Revd Charles Read who has served as Vice-Chair for many years and also stepped down at the meeting.

The new team is looking forward to the challenges of the next few months as WATCH prepares for the crucial debates in General Synod this July. But beyond July, WATCH will be broadening its focus. "We want to celebrate the gifts and perspectives that women bring to the church and affirm the renewal that their ministry brings to our corporate life" said incoming Chair Rachel Weir

BIOGRAPHIES

Revd Rachel Weir (Chair)

Rachel WeirRachel is a non stipendiary Assistant Curate serving in Oxford diocese. She read Economics and Law at Newnham College, Cambridge and then practised as a barrister before switching direction to study Theology.

Rachel trained at Cuddesdon for three years full time before being ordained in 1997. In the first part of her curacy, Rachel's time was shared between parish and national inter faith work. The second part of her curacy has been split between parish life and the life of WATCH.

Rachel joined the national committee in 2008 and was elected Vice-Chair in 2009. She looks forward to leading WATCH through the next crucial period.





Hilary Cotton
(Vice Chair)

Hilary CottonHilary Cotton is a laywoman from Guildford Diocese and a member of Diocesan Synod. In 2002 she co-founded WATCH Guildford, and served on the national WATCH Committee previously from 2003-2007.

Hilary is passionate about getting more women into leadership, and has for 20 years been coaching women and running training programmes across the public, private and third sectors to this end. In the past few years these programmes have also been greatly appreciated by clergywomen as they move into positions of greater responsibility and breadth.







Revd Mark Bennett (Vice Chair)

Revd Mark BennettRevd Mark Bennett is Team Rector in the Great Parndon Team in Harlow – a local ecumenical partnership. He studied mathematics at Sidney Sussex College, Cambridge, qualified as a Chartered Accountant with KPMG, and worked as a forensic accountant with KPMG, and lawyers Leigh, Day & Co before training for ordination at Westcott House.

During his curacy in Leeds, Mark joined WATCH and helped set up the WATCH branch in the diocese of Ripon and Leeds. He joined the National Committee in 2005, shortly after moving to Harlow.







FEBRUARY GENERAL SYNOD
Bishop Nigel McCullogh's statement about the Women Bishops legislation confirmed that the Revision Committee needed more time to consider all the submissions. It is hoped that the report and draft legislation will be out several weeks before the July General Synod sessions when time has been set aside for the draft legislation to be debated.

The good news from the statement is that the revision committee has rejected all the options that would have involved conferring some measure of jurisdiction on someone other than the diocesan bishop. The legislation that will come back to Synod will therefore be on the basis that any arrangements that are made for parishes with conscientious difficulties about women's ordination will be on the basis of delegation from the diocesan bishops.


THE REVISION COMMITTEE

The Revision Committee consists of two bodies:

1. The original Steering Committee appointed by General Synod to see the legislation through the process:

Nigel McCullogh (Chair),
Vivienne Faull*
Paula Gooder*
Alistair Magowan
Anne Stevens*
Margaret Swinson
Geoffrey Tattersall
Trevor Willmott

2. The Revision Committee itself:
Clive Mansell (Chair)
April Alexander*
Lorna Ashworth
Jonathan Baker
Pete Broadbent
Christine Hardman*
Alan Hargrave*
Martin Jarrett
Simon Killwick
Angus MacLeay
Caroline Spencer*

[* Members of WATCH or GS WATCH Plus (the WATCH fringe group at General Synod)]

The understanding is that these two bodies will work together in looking at the submissions that have been sent in and arrive at recommendations for the Feb 2010 meeting of General Synod.


back to top

RECENT APPOINTMENTS


First Woman Bishop in Finland

Irja AskolaNews has come from the Finnish Lutheran Church that they have elected Pastor, Master of Theology, Irja Askola (born 1952) as Bishop of the Diocese of Helsinki on the second round of the election, with 591 votes. She is the first woman to be elected as bishop in Finland.

Irja Askola graduated as Master of Theology in 1975, and was ordained as priest in 1988. Her home parish is Alppila. She works now as the Special Assistant in Theological Affairs for Bishop Mikko Heikka.


 

 


Canon Dr Frances Ward to be Dean of St Edmundsbury & Ipswich

Dr Frances WardWATCH member Canon Dr Frances Ward is to become the next Dean of St Edmundsbury and Ipswich Cathedral. She will be installed on Saturday 16 October at 2.30pm.

Currently a Residentiary Canon and Canon Theologian at Bradford Cathedral, Frances is responsible for all the worship. She has also taken a prominent role developing dialogue between the Church and the Muslim communities in that multi cultural city and is currently writing a book on the subject. Previously she was a vicar in the Diocese of Manchester, at the other Bury in Lancashire. She has done various jobs in parishes and as an educator since she was ordained in 1989. This includes teaching for the United Reformed Church at the Northern College in Manchester.

This means that when Frances is installed there will be FOUR women deans in the Church of England – Catherine Ogle to be installed as Dean of Birmingham this summer, with Vivienne Faull as Dean of Leicester and June Osborne as Dean of Salisbury.

Canon Lucy Winkett to be Rector of St James's Piccadilly

It has just been announced that Canon Lucy Winkett has been appointed as Rector to St James's Piccadilly. On making the announcement the The Bishop of London, Dr Richard Chartres said, "Lucy Winkett is among the most talented priests in her generation in the Church of England. I am delighted that after such a fruitful ministry at St Paul's Cathedral she will be moving to Piccadilly to work with a gifted and diverse congregation.”

We too would like to send our heartiest congratulations to Lucy on her appointment. We wish her well and much joy in her new role.


Canon Catherine Ogle to be Dean of Birmingham

Catherine OgleCanon Catherine Ogle has been appointed as the next Dean of Birmingham Cathedral. This means there will now be three women deans as Vivienne Faull is Dean of Leicester, and June Osborne is Dean of Salisbury.

Catherine is Vicar of Huddersfield at the moment. After her ordination in 1994 – one of the first – she became vicar of three parishes outside Barnsley and was also religious affairs editor for BBC Radio Leeds for four years.

WATCH wishes Catherine all the best for her future in Birmingham. She is expected to move to her new post in the summer.









Two more Women bishops in the Anglican Communion

Revd Canon Diane Jardine BruceThe Revd Canon Diane Jardine Bruce became the first woman elected a bishop in the Diocese of Los Angeles on 4 December 2009, pending the required consents.

"Diane is a skilled pastor and a proven leader," said Los Angeles diocesan Bishop Jon Bruno. "Her gifts and expertise are major assets in this diocese and the wider church and I am delighted with the opportunity for us to continue to serve together in new ways."








Revd Mary Douglas GlasspoolThe 114th annual convention of the Diocese of Los Angeles made history for the second time in as many days on 5 December 2009, electing an openly gay candidate, the Revd Mary Douglas Glasspool, as bishop suffragan, pending the required consents from the majority of the church's other dioceses.

"I'm very excited about the future of the whole Episcopal Church, and I see the Diocese of Los Angeles leading the way into that future," Glasspool said after the election. "But just for this moment, let me say again, thank you, and thanks be to our loving, surprising God."

Glasspool is the second openly gay partnered priest to be elected a bishop in the Episcopal Church. The first was Bishop Gene Robinson of New Hampshire, who was elected in 2003.

Now in April 2010 we have the news that these two women's elections as bishops have been confirmed so they were consecrated on 15 May 2010.


Another Woman bishop – and a second for Cuba!

Revd Griselda del Carpio
In a service described as “full of life and energy,” the Revd Griselda Delgado del Carpio, 55, was consecrated on 7 February 2010 as the new co-adjutor Bishop of the Episcopal Church of Cuba. 

'Hers is a theology of hope'
The pews at the Holy Trinity Cathedral in Havana were packed as about 400 people – busloads from parishes where Bishop Delgado had served as priest – gathered for the four-hour service. 

Archbishop Fred Hiltz, primate of the Anglican Church of Canada (pictured left with the new bishop), Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori, primate of The Episcopal Church, and Archbishop John Holder, the new primate of the Church of the Province of the West Indies, celebrated the Eucharist as members of the Metropolitan Council of Cuba. (The Council has overseen the Cuban church since it separated from The Episcopal Church in 1967 because of difficult relations between the governments of Cuba and the United States.)

The Episcopal Church of Cuba already has the Rt Revd Nerva Cot Aguilera serving as a suffragan bishop.

This brings the total of women bishops in the Anglican Communion to 26.  Some of these are retired.


New Canadian Bishop


Bishop Barbara AndrewsWe are delighted to hear that Revd Barbara Andrews has been appointed as the new Suffragan Bishop for the Anglican Parishes of the Central Interior in Canada.

Ever since she was ordained a priest in 1998, Barbara Andrews said she had always served the Anglican Church of Canada "kind of on the fringe of the church." That all changed in June, when she became the new suffragan (assistant) bishop for the Kamloops-based Anglican Parishes of the Central Interior (APCI). Until her election as bishop, she had worked as executive director of the Sorrento Retreat and Conference Centre in British Columbia.

Prior to that she served as a director of Christian education, and had been in street ministry for four years in an inner city parish in Winnipeg. In an interview, Bishop Andrews said her experience puts her "in a unique position because I come from a totally different experience and point of view."

This brings to 25 the total number of women bishops in the Anglican Communion: 2 in New Zealand, 2 in Australia, 5 in Canada, 1 in Cuba and 15 in USA. 19 are currently serving while 6 have retired; these 6 include 2 who are still acting as Assistant Bishop in their Diocese.

Some recently appointed Women Bishops:

Recently appointed bishops

From left to right:
Right Reverend Barbara Darling is Assistant Bishop in the Diocese of Melbourne, Province of South Australia
Right Reverend Kay Goldsworthy is Assistant Bishop in the Diocese of Perth, Province of Western Australia
Right Reverend Jane Alexander is Bishop of Edmonton, in the Diocese of Edmonton, Canada

Recent appointments in the Church of England

Congratulations to WATCH member Paula Gooder who is to be a Lay Canon of Salisbury Cathedral. If you get the Church Times you will have been reading extracts from her book This Risen Existence.
Paula used to be our Book Reviews editor for OUTLOOK. She is Canon Theologian of Birmingham Cathedral, Hon Lecturer of the University of Birmingham, and Associate Lecturer of St Mellitus College, London already!

Congratulations to Revd Christine Wilson, currently Vicar of Goring-by-Sea in Diocese of Chichester, who has been appointed as Archdeacon of Chesterfield in the Diocese of Derby. More info is available at www.derby.anglican.org/news/?i201
This brings to fifteen the number of women Archdeacons in the CofE.

Congratulations to Nikki Arthy (Nicola Arthy), Team Vicar in the Winchcombe Team Ministry, who is to be Priest in Charge of the Gloucester City Benefice and Honorary Canon of Gloucester. Nikki was on our WATCH Committee for a number of years and has written the Prayers on our Prayer cards.

We are all delighted to announce that Revd Canon Dr Judy Hunt, a member of WATCH, has been appointed as the next Archdeacon of Suffolk in the Diocese of St Edmundsbury & Ipswich. Judy, who is a member of General Synod, is currently Canon Residentiary of Chester Cathedral and Chester Diocesan Director of Ministry and Mission.
Many congratulations, Judy!
This brings to 13 the number of women Archdeacons in the CofE.
Also, another member of WATCH has been appointed as Archdeacon of Harlow in Chelmsford Diocese. He is Revd Canon (now Venerable) Martin Webster. Congratulations to you Martin!

Another Archdeacon in the Church of Wales

Congratulations also to the Revd Shirley Griffiths who will be the next Archdeacon of Wrexham and Rector of Llandegla in St Aspah diocese in Wales. Peggy Jackson became the first woman Archdeacon in Wales when she became Archdeacon of Llandaff last year – but Peggy is English and Shirley is actually Welsh, so she is the first Welsh woman to be made archdeacon in Wales! Shirley held posts in Ripon & Leeds diocese before moving to be vicar of Abergele and St George in the diocese of St Asaph.

An Archdeacon in the Church of Wales

Revd Canon Peggy Jackson
Revd Canon Peggy Jackson (left) with Revd Bernice Broggio

In a packed Cathedral in Llandaff, on a wonderfully sunny Whit Sunday the Venerable Peggy Jackson was installed as Archdeacon of Landaff along with the Rt Revd David Wilbourne, new Assistant Bishop and other Canons and Honorary Canons. Peggy was the only woman amongst them but she was warmly welcomed by the Archbishop of Wales and the whole congregation. Peggy’s supporters included her old schoolmaster, friends from the time she was an accountant, people from all the parishes in which she had served, other friends and relations and fellow campaigners from MOW, WATCH, GRAS and SMWC (Ecumenical)

After the service Peggy was greeted by many friends as she stood in the sun dressed canon’s robes, complete with an almus trimmed with fur. Next we all trouped off to the Archbishop’s reception for tea and cakes and then some of us on to the Archdeacon’s reception for wine and lasagne! Laughing, happy people then went on their way.

In the evening of Monday June 1, both bishops came  to install Peggy in Llancarfan Parish Church – a beautiful building with recently discovered frescoes, magnificently decorated with huge displays of flowers. This time the church was crowded with friends and relations and people from all three parishes. It was a relaxed and happy service with another excellent sermon by the Rt Revd Barry Morgan, Archbishop of Wales and Bishop of Llandaff. During the service we all sang with gusto two hymns by June Boyce Tillman – and one by Stewart Cross – a loyal MOW supporter until his untimely death.

More wine and food followed in the village hall with people pouring out to stand and eat in the churchyard in the light and balmy evening. It was a great welcome and an  oasis  of joy, happiness , thanks giving and laughter on our long march towards equal opportunities for women at all levels of the Anglican Church.

Revd Angela Berners-Wilson is to be made Prebendary of Wells Cathedral
Her installation was on Tuesday, 24th February at 5:15pm.
Angela was ordained at the first ordinations in Bristol Cathedral on 12th March 1994, and because the women were ordained priest in alphabetical order, Angela was actually the first woman to have hands laid on her in ordination as a priest in the Church of England. WATCH wishes her all the best in her new appointment.

First woman Bishop in Great Britain
The Lutheran Church of Great Britain consecrated the Revd Jana Jeruma-Grinberga Bishop on 17 January 2009 in the church of St Anne and St Agnes in the City of London. Jana is the first woman to be a bishop in the Lutheran Church of Great Britain. However, female bishops are not unusual in the Lutheran Church. Jana was chosen by her peers, many of whom are members of the Anglican Lutheran Society. There is much joy and anticipation about Jana's consecration.

WATCH (London) Joyous News!!

Great news for Edmonton. The Revd Marjorie Brown, previously priest-in-charge of St Matthews Upper Clapton, has been inducted as Vicar of St Mary the Virgin, Primrose Hill, London NW 3 in the Edmonton Episcopal Area. Sixteen years after the vote for women priests we have at last a woman incumbent in Edmonton. We rejoice for all of you.

Congratulations to Reverend Jan McFarlane
on her apppointment as the next Archdeacon of Norwich. Jan is currently Chaplain to the Bishop of Norwich and Diocesan Director of Communications. She will continue as Diocesan Communications Officer, combining the two roles.

The first three women ordained priest in the Province of the Indian Ocean - Madagascar
For more details click here


back to top

 

FUTURE EVENTS

2010

Wednesday 21 July 2010

WATCH (London) Summer Event and Invitation:
Prayer Pilgrimage at Westminster Abbey
6pm Meeting by the Great West Door
ou are cordially invited to a Summer Prayer Pilgrimage conducted by Canon Jane Hedges
who will welcome us and take us round the ancient grounds and gardens of the Abbey. We will end with Compline at about 7.30pm, either in St Faith's Chapel, or the Shrine of St Edward. Jane has kindly invited us to have drinks with her in her garden in Little Cloisters.
(The date is being sent to you early so that you can book this event in your diaries. I would be grateful if you could let me know if you are able to come by emailing, or, ringing me on 020 8731 9860. The Abbey likes to have a good idea of numbers attending. Do come if you are free. We would love to see you.
Sally Barnes, Secretary, WATCH (London) Committee, 94 Hamilton Road, Golders Green, NW11 9DY Tel: 020 8731 9860 / 0775734333)

August 2010
MOWatch International Conference
Dr Paula Gooder, Revd Canon Dr Jane Shaw, The Right Revd Barbara Darling and The Right Revd Kay Goldsworthy are confirmed as keynote speakers at the MOWatch International Conference in Kincumber, New South Wales, Australia in August 2010. Abstracts for presentations are invited on 'Women of Faith...Imaging God to the World'. Further info at www.mowatch.org.au

6 November 2010
WATCH Annual General Meeting
St John's Waterloo 10.30 am to 3.30pm
10.30am AGM
12 noon Eucharist

back to top

REPORTS

LONDON WATCH

Marjorie
A good number of London WATCH members attended the induction of Marjorie Brown at St Mary the Virgin Church Primrose Hill. Marjorie is the first woman incumbent in the Edmonton Area. We all wish her well.

Since the last Outlook, WATCH (London) held a Quiet Day in September conducted by Canon Lucy Winkett at St Matthews Westminster. Those who came found it a welcome time for reflection and highly supportive. Lucy provided a number of poems to help contemplation interspersed with short talks on biblical passages. If anyone would like a copy of the poems please get in touch with Sally Barnes (address and email under branch contacts). One of our members browsing in the St Matthews Library found the following quote by the present Archbishop of Canterbury in 'An Introduction to Rowan Williams' by Rupert Shortt (2003). We all thought it apt under the present circumstances.

"Theology is not a politically neutral or innocent enterprise. Like all intellectual systems, it is in fact operating in somebody's interest, and so long as it is blind to this truth it will operate in the interest of the status quo (because it is in the interest of the status quo not to be questioning or relativised)."

LONDON and SOUTHWARK WATCH

These two branches are linking closely together for joint action and events. Please would London and Southwark based members who are not on our email list and would like to be included contact either Sally Barnes (London) or Martin Carr (Southwark).

Two London newsletters have been produced and sent to members by email and post giving the latest updates and views. Members on email are kept up-to-date with requests for action, such as supporting the WATCH banner outside the February General Synod when the proposed Women Bishops legislation was being discussed and responding to the request for their 'bottom line' thoughts on women bishops legislation.

We now have our own Blog spot where you can comment on our posts and events. If you would like to add a new post – in the first instance email sarah@sarahlamming.com. The blog can be found at www.watchlondon.blogspot.com Please make good use of it.

back to top


HEREFORD WATCH

A tribute to Margaret Wickstead 1923-2008

MOW March
Apart from Margaret Wickstead (centre) who can recognise these other people from 1988?

Margaret Wickstead died in hospital in Hereford in December after a few weeks of illness. She had attended the Friends of Cathedrals national gathering at Lincoln only shortly before having a serious stroke in late November. Margaret was thrilled to see old friends and to visit the house and neighbours she'd had during her years living in Lincoln.

Margaret has meant much to many people. To the Hereford WATCH Committee, from which she had just stood down as Vice Chair, she was an inspiration. She had been a founding member of the Movement for the Ordination of Women and the photograph below shows her, with the Hereford MOW contingent, marching through London at the time of the 1988 Lambeth Conference. The march started at St Mary le Bow Church and ended on the steps of St Paul's Cathedral where the Bishops from Lambeth were attending a special service. There were about 1000 participants on the march.

Margaret's indefatigable spirit and optimism was a great source of encouragement to those of us newly ordained deacon. No one can have been more delighted than she was at our ordination as priests. She will be with us in spirit when the first women bishops are ordained. Thank you Margaret for your warm hospitality to the WATCH Committee when we held our meetings at your home. And thank you Margaret, most of all, for the confidence you showed in us as women and as priests.

Frances Hancock

Jean Mayland was at Lady Margaret Hall with Margaret and adds: "It is interesting that two founder members of MOW (Margaret and I) and one Moderator of MOW (Diana McClatchy) all graduated from LMH – but then so also did Anne Widdecombe so she probably cancels out the three of us!

It is said that Margaret's brother Philip as he faced retirement as Bishop of Worcester said "Alleluia, on we go". This was the keynote of Margaret's life too and is I think, a good watchword for us in WATCH today.

back to top


GUILDFORD WATCH

The priest, the body, the bride and the whore

The speaker at the WATCH annual lecture this year was Ali Green. Ali is a non-stipendiary minister in Monmouth and was a doctoral research student of Tina Beattie, Reader in Theology at Roehampton University. Ali received her doctorate at the end of the summer. The aim of her lecture to Guildford WATCH was to suggest ways in which women could inhabit the symbolic role of celebrant of the Eucharist in a culture which has, for most of the Church’s life, seen this as a male preserve.

Tina began with an outline of the ways in which women have been excluded from participation in the Eucharist over the centuries and quotations from theologians and others who have rationalised this: women are “unclean”, “unable to think logically” etc. The following is a comment to the Archbishop’s Commission in 1936, on the issue of women in the priesthood.

“The ministration of women will tend to produce a lowering of the spiritual tone of Christian worship...it would be impossible for the male members to be present at a service at which a woman ministered without becoming unduly conscious of her sex.”

With regard to Scripture, our relationship with the divine has over the ages, Ali suggested, been a male relationship, extending over biblical hermeneutics, genealogies, language and symbolism. Sometimes, too, the Bible uses male/female relationships to delineate for example, in the relationship between Christ and his bride, the Church, which mirrors God’s relationship with Israel in the prophesies of Hosea.
When it comes to the Eucharist, male/female issues extend beyond the obvious argument that Christ was a man and must therefore be represented by a man. Sacrifice has, suggested Ali, been a male preserve, in most faiths and cultures. Priests officiating at a sacrament whose central theme is sacrifice always were, and, it would be argued, always must be male.

So what can women do? Ali put forward important ways in which women can transform the role of celebrant at the Eucharist. By witnessing to a history of exclusion and prejudice they can, she suggested, play a key role in challenging any and all ideas of domination. Second, while stereotypes for either gender are often misleading, women’s traditional role means that the stereotype of care and nurture, can be taken into the Eucharist and uncover a range of symbolic new meanings.

Women are made in the image of God and as priests must mediate this image, just as men have done hitherto. Ali was anxious not to be seen as diminishing the role of male priests, stressing instead that the roles of male and female priests complemented each other. Together, male and female priests can minister to the whole body of the Church in ways not possible up to now. Her lecture ended thus:
“Women and men serving together as priests witness to the God-intended relationship between the sexes of mutuality and reciprocity. Neither is dominant or subordinate, neither more or less in Imago Dei; both play an equal and vital role in being part of the Body of Christ. The Eucharist can now fulfil its destiny as an eschatological celebration that allows all believers to affirm their own identity and hope in God as bodily, sexed beings with a shared spiritual ethos expressed in diverse ways according to individuals’ ways of being in the world...All worshippers flourish at the wedding banquet in the presence of God beyond language, embodiment and gender. In communion with God through the symbolic use of the body, they experience most intimately the aspiration to become divine in a bodily participation with God. The true and full significance of the wedding feast can unfold as the female body fully participates in the narrative of faith.”

Bishop’s new Advisory Group in Guildford Diocese

Hilary Cotton reports: In a new venture, the Bishop of Guildford has appointed a group of women (4 clergy, one lay) whose concern is the ministry of ordained women.
This group:
• Succeeds the role of Diocesan Advisor in Women’s Ministry
• Aims to ensure that clergy appointments comply with the spirit of Equal Opportunities legislation
• Monitors statistics on the numbers and roles of clergywomen
• Assesses the adequacy of pastoral care for clergywomen
• With Diocesan senior staff, provides support and representation for clergywomen in situations of conflict or confrontation.
• Liaises with the national network for Diocesan Advisors on Women’s Ministry on current issues
• Reports regularly to the Bishop and senior staff
As the lay member of this Group, I am delighted that it is taking on a number of tasks that WATCH has been doing in Guildford, and which I have often advocated as more properly the responsibility of the Diocese. This frees WATCH Guildford to do other things...we have yet to get together and discuss what!

back to top

 
 

Site Map

Press contact: Sally Barnes 020 8731 9860 / 07759 343335
General enquires: info@womenandthechurch.org